Round Two of Diva Dirt’s Flawless Face-Off was one of the most competitive yet—every single category came down to the wire. The margins were razor-thin, with each winner claiming their crown by just 3–5% of the total vote, which translates to a difference of only a dozen or so votes. So trust us when we say: every single vote truly counted.
From shocking debuts to unforgettable entrance themes, from standout Diva Search legends to overlooked SmackDown match gems, this round celebrated some of the most defining (and underrated!) moments of the 1998–2008 era. Below are your hard-fought, well-earned Round Two winners—and keep an eye on the comments for the full category rankings!
Most Memorable Debut/Return: Gail Kim Wins the Women’s Championship in Her Debut
There are debuts… and then there’s Gail Kim’s debut on the June 30, 2003 episode of Raw. Kim received a few vignettes prior to her debut but she entered the battle royal as a complete unknown to the WWE Universe. Gail shocked the world by outlasting the division’s biggest names, eliminating Victoria last to win the WWE Women’s Championship—on her very first night. It wasn’t just a surprise—it was history-making.
This win instantly placed Gail in the record books and proved that she was a force to be reckoned with. While her first WWE run may have been underappreciated, this debut set the tone for the groundbreaking in-ring work she would go on to deliver both in WWE and beyond. Gail’s journey began in the most unforgettable way possible, and this award ensures her debut gets the flowers it’s always deserved.
Best Theme Song: Victoria – “All The Things She Said”
If ever a theme song perfectly matched a character’s chaotic energy, it was Victoria’s “All The Things She Said.” With its haunting lyrics and unrelenting beat, this track announced her arrival with an edge that no other woman in the division could match.
Paired with her unhinged persona and intense physicality, the theme turned Victoria into a walking storm. The moment that music hit, you knew business was about to pick up. It was loud, it was wild, and it was unmistakably Victoria. For many fans, it remains one of the most instantly recognizable and vibe-heavy themes of the era—and this win only cements its legacy.
Favorite Diva Search Contestant: Layla El
The 2006 Diva Search gave us a star that outlasted, outperformed, and outshined expectations: Layla El. What began as a televised competition turned into the launchpad for one of the most decorated diva search careers.
Layla brought charm, athleticism, humor, and versatility, growing from underdog newbie into one-half of the unforgettable LayCool duo. She broke the Diva Search mold by proving she wasn’t just a contest winner—she was a full-package performer who earned her spot among the best. This win is a nod not just to her start, but to the superstar she became.
Favorite SmackDown Match: Michelle McCool vs. Maryse – Diva’s Championship Match (w/ Maria as Special Guest Referee)
This underrated gem from the SmackDown archives showcased everything the 2008 Smackdown Divas division was capable of. Michelle McCool and Maryse, both at pivotal moments in their careers, delivered a match that was equal parts tension, storytelling, and athleticism—with the added spark of Maria as the special guest referee.
Whether it was the rising stakes, the sharp chemistry between Michelle and Maryse, or the tension between Kanellis and McCool, this match offered more than it was ever given credit for. It’s a reminder that the SmackDown women’s division quietly carved out its own legacy—and now, that legacy gets a well-earned spotlight thanks to this win.
Don’t forget to check the comments below for the full rankings in each category—some of these were so close, you’ll want to see just how tight the race was!
And get ready—Round 3 voting kicks off tomorrow, with four new categories up for grabs. Stay tuned and keep those votes coming!
